“Chinese maple” is not one plant. Nurseries and garden centers use the name for at least three different things: Shantung maple (Acer truncatum), trident maple (Acer buergerianum) and the houseplant-like flowering maple (Abutilon), which is not a maple at all. A Japanese maple (Acer palmatum) is a more defined group, although it includes hundreds of cultivars. Which comparison you need depends on which “Chinese maple” is on the label.
The short answer: the main difference: the trees sold as Chinese maples, Shantung maple and trident maple, are tougher, sun-loving small shade trees, about 20 to 35 feet tall, that tolerate heat and drought. Japanese maple is a smaller, more delicate ornamental, to about 25 feet, that prefers dappled shade and evenly moist soil and can scorch in sun, wind or drought (all NC State Extension). “Chinese lantern” or flowering maple (Abutilon) is a frost-tender shrub in the mallow family with maple-shaped leaves.
Side-by-side comparison
| Shantung maple | Trident maple | Japanese maple | Flowering maple | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Botanical name | Acer truncatum | Acer buergerianum | Acer palmatum | Abutilon hybrids |
| True maple? | Yes | Yes | Yes | No (mallow family) |
| Size | 20 to 25 ft tall, 15 to 20 ft wide | 25 to 35 ft tall, 20 to 30 ft wide | Up to about 25 ft; many cultivars much smaller | 2 to 4 ft in cold areas, 8 to 10 ft in the tropics |
| Leaves | 5-lobed, square base | 3 forward-facing lobes | 5 to 9 deep lobes, often finely cut | Maple-like, on a shrub |
| Light | Full sun to part shade | Full sun | Dappled shade | Bright light |
| Toughness | Heat and drought tolerant once established | Tolerates wind, salt, drought, pollution and compaction | Scorches with sun, wind or drought | Frost-tender; outdoors year-round only in zones 9 and 10 |
Size and tolerance figures are from the NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox profiles for each plant.
Shantung maple (Acer truncatum)
NC State describes Shantung (Shangtung) maple, also called purple blow maple, as a deciduous tree native to China that grows 20 to 25 feet tall and 15 to 20 feet wide with a dense, rounded crown. Its leaves are 5-lobed, and the species name refers to their square-cut base. Fall color is yellow, orange and red. It is heat and drought tolerant once established and grows in average, well-drained soil in full sun to partial shade.
Compared with a Japanese maple, it is larger and much more forgiving of a hot, sunny yard, but its leaves are simpler and less finely cut. NC State notes that it is often confused with Norway maple and with the hybrid Crimson Sunset maple, so check the label.
Trident maple (Acer buergerianum)
Trident maple gets its name from its leaves, which NC State describes as having three forward-facing lobes like a trident. It grows 25 to 35 feet tall and 20 to 30 feet wide with a rounded form. Mature trees have exfoliating bark that shows orange-brown inner bark. NC State lists it as tolerant of wind, salt, drought, air pollution and soil compaction, and suggests it as a street tree or a shade tree for smaller spaces. It is also widely used for bonsai.
Trident maple is the toughest of the group. Choose it where a Japanese maple would struggle: a hot parking strip, a windy corner or a yard with heavy soil.
Recommended Products
Bloodgood Japanese Red Maple Tree in a ABP Container
Premium Quantity: Each pack contains 15 high-quality blue Japanese maple seeds curated for gardeners looking to grow their own ornamental Acer Palmatum trees
For sale is a Japanese Red Maple Trees that is approximately 10 to 16 inches tall and shipped in a quart pot
Japanese maple (Acer palmatum)
Japanese maple is the most ornamental of the group, and the hardest to place well. NC State describes it as a small deciduous tree up to about 25 feet. It advises planting in dappled shade and evenly moist, well-drained soil, protected from drying winds, and notes it may suffer leaf scorch with too much sun, wind or drought. Late spring frosts can also damage new leaves.
The trade-off is the range of choice. Cultivars vary from dwarf mounds to small upright trees, with green, red, purple or variegated leaves, some finely dissected. Our guide to how big Japanese maples grow lists sizes by type, and our Japanese maple care guide covers siting and watering.
Recommended Products
Brilliant Fall Color: these heirloom seeds grow into scarlet maple trees to 80 feet with red fall foliage and reddish twigs, a classic shade tree and fall tree for yards and outdoor gardens.
Slow growing and often dwarf in appearance, 'butterfly' Has a very interesting display of leaf Sizes and shapes.
Quantity and Variety: 30+ seeds of Acer palmatum; A curated mix focusing on dwarf and red-leaved Japanese Maple varieties for ornamental use
Flowering maple (Abutilon): not a maple
If the “Chinese maple” you saw was a shrub with bell-shaped flowers, often in a pot, it was probably Abutilon. NC State lists its common names as Chinese bellflower, Chinese lantern, flowering maple and parlor maple. It belongs to the mallow family (Malvaceae), not the maple family. The leaves look like maple leaves, but the plant is a frost-tender tropical shrub that can live outdoors year-round only in zones 9 and 10. It grows 8 to 10 feet in tropical areas and 2 to 4 feet in colder places, where it is usually grown in containers or as a summer annual.
Recommended Products
Raise seedlings for an ornamental tree collection or a future bonsai training project.
Seasonal Color Display: Leaves stay red for most of the summer and turn greenish red during hot weather in the southern part of its range, with reddish fall color providing year-round visual interest
VERSATILE ORNAMENTAL: Green Japanese Maple Tree (Acer Palmatum) transforms landscapes with vibrant green foliage that turns brilliant yellow in fall, complemented by striking red flowers and red whirligigs.
Which should you plant?
- A hot, sunny or windy yard, or a street tree: trident maple, or Shantung maple.
- A sheltered spot with afternoon shade and moist soil: Japanese maple.
- The best fall color in a small tree that takes sun: Shantung maple.
- A flowering patio plant: Abutilon, brought indoors before frost in cold climates.
To compare sizes with other maples before you buy, see the different types of maple trees. For spacing, see our maple spacing chart.
Sources
- Acer truncatum (Purple Blow Maple, Shangtung Maple), NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox
- Acer buergerianum (Trident Maple), NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox
- Acer palmatum (Japanese Maple), NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox
- Abutilon (Flowering Maple, Chinese Lantern), NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox
Top photo: Photo (c)2006 Derek Ramsey (Ram-Man), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons









